Mustahil Dhati = Intrinsically Impossible

Mustahil ‘Aradi = Contingently Impossible

Some people posit the theory that:

A lie told by Allah (God) is hypothetically possible (ja’iz ‘aqli) in the very limited sense of not being intrinsically impossible (mustahil dhati), it is nevertheless contingently impossible (mustahil ‘aradi) since He has  informed us of His truthfulness in the Quran.

There are people in this world who hurl such insults at Allah, the Creator who created them, and there are people who defend them. We seek refuge in Allah from such blasphemy.

What’s that, the above is not an insult? Ok, how about I say:

It is hypothetically possible (ja’iz ‘aqli) for the speaker of such rubbish and its defender to be a despicable idiot and a buffoon full of flaws with no basic understanding of Islam or tawhid!

Does that sound like an insult?

What’s that? I’ve lost my adab. How can I speak in such a tone about a fellow human being who also claims to be a Muslim? Well if he can attribute flaws to his Creator, whom he believes in, why can’t I attribute flaws to this person?

Oh that’s right, he was only talking about the “hypothetical possibility” of Allah lieing, may Allah protect us from such filthy beliefs by the tawassul and blessing of His beloved Habib Muhammad, sal’Allahu ‘alaihi wa’sallam.

My friend, I too, am talking about the “hypothetical possibility” of such a person being an absolute idiot unqualified in Islam and totally bereft of any understanding of tawhid.

What’s the fuss all about?

If my statement sounds like an insult to a human, then be damned sure, the first statement is definitely an insult to Allah, our Creator and consequently kufr.

Even if the reader doesn’t consider my comments to be insulting to the speaker and the defender of the initial quote, the initial comment quoted is still kufr. Allah’s Speech does not pertain to His Power. So there is no question of “possibilities” regarding His Speech as it is NOT a creation but rather eternal and divinely perfect and absolute without any changes attributed to it. Further details on this topic can be found on this blog.

Disclaimer: No accusations are made at any specific individuals. The problem is tackled at a generic and ideological level. We respect and dignify all our Muslim brothers and sisters and uphold their honor and dignity unless proven otherwise by witnesses and confessions.  

Even if someone feels some specific individuals have been insulted, explicitly or implicitly, they should worry about showing respect and humility and servitude towards their Creator, Allah, subhanahu wa’ta’aala, against whom such filth has been uttered, rather than try and uphold the empty honor and dignity of such individuals who utter such disrespectful comments towards their Creator.

In fact, if they feel an insult was hurled at their dignitaries by the author of this blog, their distress at, and the acknowledgement of, the fact that an insult was hurled- would be blatant proof that their initial comments about the “hypothetical possibility” of Allah lieing is an insult hurled at their Creator, as all that has been done is that their ugly comments have been turned towards them. They would have fallen in their own trap.

May Allah protect all Muslims from such filthy beliefs and such fitnah unleashed by Sunni-sounding individuals and keep them steadfast on the path of true Ahlus Sunnah wal’Jama’ah. ameen by the tawassul of His Blessed Habib, sal’Allahu ‘alaihi wa’sallam.

Any comments are welcome.